Top Realtors & Real Estate Agents in Bartholomew County, Indiana

A+ Rating from the Better Business Bureau

Top Realtors & Real Estate Agents in Bartholomew County, Indiana


If you are looking for a top rated realtor or real estate agent to help you with the purchase or sale of real estate in Bartholomew County, Indiana, contact White Stag Realty. Our office has handled hundreds of real estate transactions and has over three-hundred five star Google Reviews. Our office believes that coupling superior service with better pricing is the pathway to success. Contact our office to find out why so many people have trusted White Stag Realty to handle their real estate transactions.
You can also read about some of our top Bartholomew County Realtors below:

Josh Dilmaghani

Josh Dilmaghani Top Rated Realtor in Indiana

It is difficult to find a more qualified real estate agent than Josh Dilmaghani. Josh has supervised over $220 million in residential transactions. Josh is considered to be a leading industry expert and has been cited multiple times by newspapers and local news stations. He has also been a featured guest on multiple podcasts with a focus on the real estate market. Josh’s strengths include a deep understanding of state laws and an unwavering desire to do what is best for his clients.

Phone: 317-965-4849

Email: joshdilmaghani@whitestagrealty.com

Courtney Hull

Cortney Hull Top Real Estate Agent in Indiana

Realtor Cortney Hull has successfully closed over $20 million in real estate transactions. She brings valuable experience working with home buyers, sellers, and investors, always delivering personalized service with a sharp focus on her clients’ best interests. Cortney is known for her responsiveness, reliability, and unwavering advocacy—guiding clients with care, clarity, and confidence through every step of the process. Her genuine commitment to helping her clients achieve their real estate goals is what truly sets her apart from other Indiana real estate agents.

Phone: 317-371-8178

Email: cortneyhull@whitestagrealty.com

Sarah Schaefer

Sarah Schaefer Top Low Commission Buyer's Agent and Sellers Agent for Real Estate in Indiana

With over $22 million in real estate sold and counting, real estate agent Sarah Schaefer has built a reputation as a top producer known for her sharp negotiation skills, creative problem-solving, and deep understanding of the local market. Whether working with first-time homebuyers, seasoned investors, or clients making their next big move, Sarah brings a personalized, results-driven approach to every transaction. Her experience, professionalism, and client-first mindset make her a trusted partner throughout the buying or selling process. Investor-friendly, detail-oriented, and always advocating for her clients’ best interests, Sarah is the real estate agent you want on your side.

Phone: 317-833-4397

Email: sarahschaefer@whitestagrealty.com

Whether you’re searching for a single-family home, a low-maintenance condominium, or vacant land to build your future residence, this page brings together a wide range of residential properties currently for sale throughout Bartholomew County, Indiana. Buyers can explore a wide range of housing options, from established neighborhoods with move-in-ready homes to condos offering convenience and amenities, as well as undeveloped lots ideal for custom construction. By browsing available listings in one place, you can compare locations, property types, and price ranges to find the opportunity that best fits your lifestyle, long-term goals, and budget in Indiana’s residential real estate market. This page brings together a wide range of options for buyers who are at the start of their search. However, if you contact our office, we can set up a free no obligation search for you with much more specific criteria that is tailored to your individual needs. Clients looking to buy a home can enjoy tailored property searches, while homeowners looking to sell can benefit from our expertise in market analysis and listing strategies.
Or if you have a specific area in mind, take a look at listings in the following locations:

Current Indiana Real Estate Market Trends Over the Last 90 Days

It is important to remember that real estate trends can change quickly and can vary from city to city or even neighborhood to neighborhood, but these are the market trends and patterns that we have generally observed over the last 90 days as of April 21, 2026. Over this period, Indiana’s housing market has shown signs of modest growth and increasing activity. Median home sale prices have risen approximately 2–4% year-over-year, with recent monthly figures landing around $270,000–$285,000 depending on the data source, reflecting steady upward pressure amid limited supply in many areas. Inventory levels have increased modestly—active listings are up roughly 5–9% compared to the same time last year—giving buyers slightly more options than in previous periods while still maintaining a relatively tight overall market (often around 2 months of supply in key metrics). Sales activity has been resilient, with closed sales holding steady or rising slightly (around 1% year-over-year in recent months) and a noticeable surge in new listings and pending contracts during the early spring months. Homes have generally spent 30–50 days on the market on average, with some reports showing faster movement in competitive segments (as low as 19 days from listing to pending in March). Sellers continue to receive strong percentages of their asking prices, often in the 95–99% range, indicating sustained buyer interest despite modest affordability challenges from mortgage rates hovering near or above 6%. Price per square foot has also edged upward, and certain sub-markets (particularly in southern and northwest Indiana) have experienced stronger pricing gains. Overall, the last 90 days point to a balanced but still seller-leaning environment statewide, with improving inventory helping to ease some pressure while home values continue their gradual climb. Buyers may find more negotiating room in areas with newer listings, while well-priced properties in desirable neighborhoods often move quickly.

The Home Buying and Selling Process in Bartholomew County, Indiana

Navigating the real estate market in Bartholomew County involves several key steps for both buyers and sellers. For buyers, the process typically begins with obtaining pre-approval for a mortgage to understand your budget, followed by working with a knowledgeable real estate agent to search for properties that match your needs in areas like Columbus or Hope. Once a suitable home is found, you’ll make an offer, negotiate terms, conduct inspections, and close the deal with the help of local title companies familiar with Indiana regulations. Sellers start by assessing their property’s value through comparable sales in the county, preparing the home for showings, and listing it with an agent who understands the local market dynamics. Effective marketing, open houses, and skilled negotiation lead to a successful closing. Agents from firms like White Stag Realty can provide guidance throughout, ensuring a smooth transaction in this vibrant Indiana community.

How to Find the Right Realtor for You

Selecting the ideal real estate agent is crucial for a successful experience in Bartholomew County’s competitive market. Begin by seeking recommendations from friends or family who have recently bought or sold property in the area, and review online testimonials to gauge reputation. Look for agents with extensive local knowledge, such as familiarity with neighborhoods in Columbus and surrounding townships, and a track record of handling transactions similar to yours. Interview several candidates to discuss their approach, communication style, and availability, ensuring they align with your goals. Consider their marketing strategies for sellers or search techniques for buyers. Reputable agencies like White Stag Realty often feature agents who prioritize client needs and deliver personalized service, helping you feel confident in your choice.

Questions to Ask When Choosing a Real Estate Agent

When evaluating potential real estate agents in Bartholomew County, prepare a list of targeted questions to ensure they meet your requirements. Inquire about their years of experience in the local market and the number of recent transactions in areas like Columbus or Edinburgh. Ask how they plan to market your property if selling, or how they will tailor searches if buying. Discuss their communication preferences and response times to keep you informed. Probe into their knowledge of current market trends, such as inventory levels and average days on market in the county. Finally, clarify their fee structure and any additional services they offer. Agents at White Stag Realty are equipped to address these inquiries with transparency and expertise.

Why Bartholomew County is a Great Place to Live

Bartholomew County offers a compelling mix of small-town warmth, economic stability, and cultural richness that appeals to families and professionals alike. Centered around the city of Columbus, known globally for its modernist architecture, the county boasts a strong manufacturing base with major employers like Cummins contributing to a robust job market and median household incomes around $80,000. Residents enjoy a high quality of life with access to over 25 miles of People Trails for outdoor activities, scenic parks like Mill Race Park, and historic sites such as Zaharakos Ice Cream Parlor. The area’s commitment to innovation is evident in its art installations, festivals, and community events, fostering a welcoming environment. With low crime rates, affordable housing options, and proximity to larger cities via Interstate 65, Bartholomew County provides a balanced lifestyle where nature, culture, and opportunity converge.

Popular Neighborhoods and Communities

  • Tipton Lakes

    Tipton Lakes is a master-planned community in southwest Columbus featuring private lakes, walking trails, and a variety of housing styles from single-family homes to townhouses. Its emphasis on outdoor recreation, including boating and community events, makes it ideal for active families seeking a serene yet connected lifestyle close to top-rated schools and downtown amenities.

  • Shadow Creek Farms

    Located on the north side of Columbus, Shadow Creek Farms offers upscale homes with spacious lots and modern amenities, appealing to those desiring privacy and luxury. The neighborhood’s proximity to golf courses and parks enhances its appeal for outdoor enthusiasts, while its family-oriented atmosphere supports long-term residency in a growing area.

  • Parkside

    Parkside is an established neighborhood with tree-lined streets and a mix of architectural styles, conveniently situated near downtown Columbus. Residents appreciate the walkability to shops, schools, and cultural attractions, making it a favorite for young professionals and families who value community engagement and easy access to local events.

  • McCulloughs Run

    This neighborhood features affordable homes in a quiet setting with nearby parks and trails, ideal for first-time buyers or those seeking a suburban feel. Its strong sense of community and access to recreational facilities contribute to a relaxed lifestyle while remaining close to employment hubs in the county.

  • Hope

    As a small town in northern Bartholomew County, Hope provides a charming rural community with historic appeal and affordable housing options. Known for its tight-knit residents and local museum, it’s perfect for those preferring a slower pace with easy commutes to Columbus for work and amenities.

Schools and Education

Education in Bartholomew County is supported by dedicated public districts and private institutions, offering diverse options for families. The focus on academic excellence, extracurricular activities, and community involvement helps students thrive in a supportive environment.

Public School Districts

  • Bartholomew Consolidated School Corporation (BCSC)

    Serving over 11,000 students across Columbus and much of the county, BCSC operates 11 elementary schools, three high schools, two middle schools, and specialized centers. Recognized as a top employer in Indiana, the district emphasizes STEM education, arts, and athletics, with high graduation rates and programs that prepare students for college or careers in local industries like manufacturing.

  • Flat Rock-Hawcreek School Corporation

    This smaller district covers the northern region, including Hope, with about 900 students in elementary and junior-senior high schools. It prides itself on personalized attention, strong community ties, and improvements in test scores, offering vocational training and extracurriculars that reflect the area’s rural heritage.

Major Private Schools

  • St. Bartholomew Catholic School

    A K-8 Catholic school in Columbus serving around 387 students, it integrates faith-based learning with academics, athletics, and service projects. The school’s welcoming community and focus on holistic development make it a popular choice for families seeking values-centered education.

  • Columbus Christian School

    Offering PK-12 education to over 400 students, this Christian institution emphasizes biblical principles alongside rigorous academics and sports like basketball and volleyball. Its comprehensive approach supports student growth in a nurturing environment.

  • St. Peter’s Lutheran School

    A PK-8 Lutheran school in Columbus with about 200 students, it combines religious instruction with strong academic programs and extracurriculars. The school’s commitment to character building and community service appeals to families valuing faith-integrated learning.

  • ABC-Stewart Montessori School

    Serving PK-6 students, this Montessori-oriented school promotes hands-on, child-led learning in a diverse environment. With small class sizes, it fosters independence and creativity, ideal for families interested in alternative educational methods.

Secondary Schools

  • Columbus North High School (BCSC)

    One of two high schools in BCSC, it serves grades 9-12 with advanced placement courses, athletics, and clubs. Known for academic excellence and competitive sports, it prepares students for higher education and local career opportunities.

  • Columbus East High School (BCSC)

    The other BCSC high school for grades 9-12, it offers diverse programs including career-technical education and arts. Its focus on student achievement and community involvement helps graduates succeed in various paths.

  • Hauser Junior-Senior High School (Flat Rock-Hawcreek)

    Serving grades 7-12 in Hope, this combined school provides a supportive setting with extracurriculars and vocational training. Its smaller size allows for individualized attention and strong teacher-student relationships.

Best Realtors in Bartholomew County, Indiana Reviews

If you are looking for a top rated real estate agent in Bartholomew County, White Stag's five star Google Reviews speak for themselves. Read our client reviews to see why so many people have trusted White Stag Real Estate Agents for representation in residential real estate transactions.

Additional Resources for Residential Transactions

Many of our buyers ask us for suggestions on home inspection and lending services. You are free to use any service provider you wish, but our past clients have generally had positive experiences with the following providers:

Dan Duffer is a dedicated mortgage professional who believes the best home loan conversations start right at your kitchen table. Known for keeping things refreshingly simple and real, he avoids the usual industry jargon and instead focuses on creative, outside-the-box solutions tailored to each client's unique life and goals. As both an expert guide and patient teacher, Dan empowers families to take charge of their decisions, providing clear facts and personalized plans that truly fit—ensuring clients feel confident, excited, and fully prepared every step of the way. With his unwavering commitment to turning "someday" into "today," Dan Duffer helps people move from dreaming about homeownership to making it happen, one straightforward conversation at a time.

  • First American Title

Phone: 317-214-6678

  • Trademark Title

Phone: 317-588-9988

  • HouseMaster Serving the Heartland

Phone: 317-209-9100

  • 2018 © White Stag Realty, LLC All rights reserved