Josh Dilmaghani Rated White Stag’s Best

#1 Top Real Estate Agent for Shelby County, Indiana


Serving Shelbyville, Edinburgh, Fairland, Morristown and St. Paul

At White Stag Realty, LLC, it is always difficult to choose which of our agent’s is the top agent for a county each year.  Admittedly, this decision is somewhat subjective and we have many great real estate agents to pick form.  However, for 2023, White Stag Realty’s Top Agent for the year in Shelby County, Indiana is Josh Dilmaghani.  But don’t take our word for it; here are Josh’s top 10 most recent client reviews: 

★★★★★ I am a realtor from Northwest Indiana and my brother lives down in Bloomington and asked for me to help him find a house. I immediately called Josh and he had Austin service my brother. Both showed an amazing amount of service and respect to myself and my brother and found a house he was looking for. Will send all of my referrals to this team from now on, and I assure you that you will be very happy with the service that White Stag provides!

          ~ Connor

★★★★★ Josh Dilmaghani is the”Rock Star” among realtors! My husband and I had previously used F.C. Tucker for the last sale of our house and the building of our current home. This time we wanted a better experience and a realtor that would listen to our needs. After careful searching and reading reviews, I came across White Stag Realty. My husband and I were so impressed with Josh’s professionalism, expertise, and exuberance upon our first meeting with him. Our process with him as been amazing because of continued and consistent communication and with a fair rate! We feel like we got a value out of our home equal to the value put into it. Josh understands that and treats his clients with respect and candor. I highly recommend White Stag Realty to anyone who is selling or buying a home in Central Indiana. They are the premier real estate agency!

          ~ Michelle

★★★★★ White Stag Realty was excellent and Josh Dilmaghani was proficient in every facets of our transactions from discussion, to counseling prior to listing, to assisting in setting pricing according to current market. Photos were profession quality, listing information was extremely beneficial to inspiring interest. Sale was quick, (listed one day and had 10 appointment to show the next) and we had an offer over list within 24hrs. We went from “offer” to “close” in less than 30days!!! This was the simplest closing we had ever experienced and we handled our end out of state. Josh was even instrumental in helping me with some technical challenges of sending 25 signed/notarized documents back to the Title Co. Josh kept us informed and updated every step of the way and I have the confidence that he handles all his clients in the manner in which he handle my wife and I. If you are looking for great real estate company and personal agent to handle your needs you will not go wrong with White Stag Realty and Josh Dilmaghani. Thank you for a GREAT EXPERIENCE!!!! Max & Rebecca Mills

          ~ Max

★★★★★ Josh was very professional. honest and hardworking. He went the extra mile in everything we asked of him through the listing and selling process. His advice and market knowledge was spot on. Josh was extremely responsive to calls, texts and emails and always had an answer. Easy to work with, very friendly. We started out for sale by owner and Josh reached out to us in hopes that we would retain him as our selling agent, we pushed back for a few weeks but he kept calling not just to get our business but answered questions and provided advice before we retained his service. The best part was a gift that he presented us at closing that fit into a collection we have, he was detailed and cared enough about us to do that. Very nice touch Highly recommend his services

          ~ Edward

★★★★★ My family and I recently had the pleasure of having Josh as our realtor. He was fantastic! Not only was Josh extremely responsive during our house buying process, but he was also very patient with all we were looking for on our wish list. He found us our dream home and we couldn’t be happier with our decision. His personality is the best and our kids loved him as much as we did, which is a huge bonus, especially with teenage boys! If we had to do it all over again, we wouldn’t change a thing. Just today, Josh came to our new home and brought us a very special house warming gift which ties into phrases we used during our closing time. We are proud to hang it in our home with it being a great reminder of Josh every time we see it. I highly recommend White Stag Realty! #TeamJOSH!

          ~ Bard

★★★★★ Josh D. is the ultimate professional and will deliver you a superb realty experience. From start to finish, Josh was very proactive in his communication and updates on a consistent basis. He went above and beyond to help reduce the stress that is traditionally associated with buying/selling a home. Josh D. is a class act and he will not disappoint. We will definitely be working with Josh D. again for any future real estate transactions and will be sure to refer our friends/family his way as well. We had our inside joke about “landing the plane” throughout the entire transaction, and Josh D. definitely “landed the plane” with a super-smooth landing. Thank you for the teaming Josh D. – Sincerely, Josh B.

          ~ Joshua

★★★★★ White Stag Realty is a full service real estate company that goes above and beyond to deliver for their clients. Josh is an amazing realtor. He’s communicative, professional, and will absolutely go to bat for his clients to make sure they have an awesome experience whether buying or selling their home. And the crazy part is that they do what they do and charge a lower commission than most of their competitors. That low commission is very helpful to people looking to sell their homes, since it means you save money in the process. I would recommend White Stag Realty to anyone I know. Great service at a low cost is tough to beat!

          ~ Jacob

★★★★★ My wife and I do not move frequently. After interviewing a couple of realtors we certainly DID NOT think we required a realtor to sell our home of 19 years, then we met Josh. His enthusiasm, and methodology towards how he sells homes is different, and his pricing structure convienced me to let him take the responsibility. We are very busy people, and his communication with us was to the point, and frequent enough that we never had opportunity to question where we were in the selling process, and he did not interfere with our day time careers with unecessary dialog. The house sold quick, and the closing went smoothly, and in the end we actually gained a new friend.

          ~ Anthony

★★★★★ Our house sold by Josh and we can’t say enough about the great service we recieved from him as our realtor. He kept us well informed through the entire process. I am sure he had other clients but he always treated us as if we were his top priority. He was more then a realtor to us and we consider him a friend. I feel like he would do anything to help you get your house sold. We will definitely refer our friends and family to him and we will definitely turn to him when we purchase another home. Thank you Josh for everything, you are one of the nicest people we have ever met and feel blessed to know you and work with you. Thanks again

          ~ Tom & Jenni

★★★★★ What can I say about Josh Dilmaghani? I mean, this guy was outstanding! He made sure everything we needed taken care of was TAKEN CARE OF. He always kept us informed, was very professional, very honest and super friendly. This was our first home and I wont lie, it was stressful with all the upgrades the house needed but Josh was always on top of everything and made sure we got the best deal possible and all the repairs were done. I highly recommend this guy for anyone buying a home, dont matter if youre a first time buyer or not, he will work with you until you are satisfied. Thank you Josh for everything, we really appreciate everything you did for us.

          ~ Jhonny

★★★★★ If you’re looking for a great realtor look no more, Josh is your guy! He is professional and very knowledgeable. He is very responsive. We had lots of questions during our home selling process and he always responded quickly which helped to lessen any stress or concerns we may have been feeling at that time. He’s a great listener as well. He knew our home selling goals and he did a great job guiding us and helping us to reach those goals. We had 5 star experience from the beginning to the very end. Josh even took the time to give us a very thoughtful gift at closing. We feel very fortunate that we had Josh as our realtor and you will too!

          ~ Michelle 

Josh serves all of Shelby County, Indiana including Shelbyville, Edinburgh, Fairland, Morristown and St. Paul.

If you are looking for top rated real estate agents for a real estate transaction in Shelby County, Indiana, contact White Stag Realty.  Our office has handled hundreds of real estate transactions and has over 200  five star Google ReviewsWe have brokers and realtors who handle transactions in the entire county, including Shelbyville, Edinburgh, Fairland, Morristown and St. Paul. Our office believes that coupling superior service with better pricing is the pathway to success.  If you want to find out why so many Hoosiers have made the switch to White Stag Realty, call our office at 317-965-4849 to learn more or click here to visit our home page or here to contact our office on the web.  

Current Market Conditions in Shelby County, Indiana

The Shelby County, Indiana real estate market has been on a roller coaster ride in recent years. According to the RocketHomes Housing Market Report, the median home sold price in Shelby County was $210,055, up 13.3% from last year. However, the number of homes sold was down 12.3% year-over-year. This suggests that the market is still relatively hot, but buyers are becoming more cautious.

One of the biggest challenges facing the Shelby County real estate market is the lack of inventory. There are simply not enough homes on the market to meet the demand from buyers. This is driving up prices and making it difficult for buyers to find the perfect home.

Another challenge is the rising interest rates. The average interest rate on a 30-year fixed mortgage has increased significantly in recent months. This makes it more expensive to borrow money to buy a home.

Despite these challenges, the Shelby County real estate market is still expected to remain relatively strong in the coming months. The county’s economy is growing, and the population is increasing. This is creating a strong demand for housing.

Here is a more detailed look at the Shelby County real estate market, including trends in home prices, inventory levels, and days on market:

Home Prices

The median home sold price in Shelby County has been steadily increasing in recent years. Three years ago, the median home sold price was $161,000. Two years ago, it increased to $185,000. Last year, it increased to $200,000. This year, it increased to $220,000.

The median home sold price in Shelby County is expected to continue to increase in the coming months, but at a slower pace than in previous years. This is due to the rising interest rates and inflation.

Inventory Levels

The inventory of homes for sale in Shelby County has been declining in recent years. 

The low inventory levels in Shelby County are driving up home prices and making it difficult for buyers to find the perfect home. The inventory levels are expected to remain low in the coming months, which will continue to put pressure on home prices.

Days on Market

The average number of days that a home stays on the market in Shelby County has been decreasing in recent years.  

The low days on market in Shelby County is a sign that the market is still relatively hot. Homes are selling quickly, which is good news for sellers but bad news for buyers.

Overall, the Shelby County real estate market is still expected to remain relatively strong in the coming months. The county’s economy is growing, and the population is increasing. This is creating a strong demand for housing. However, the market is facing some challenges, such as the lack of inventory and the rising interest rates. Buyers should be prepared to act quickly if they find a home that they love, and they should budget for a higher monthly mortgage payment due to the rising interest rates.

Why Using a Top-Rated Real Estate Agency Like White Stag Is a Good Idea

When buying or selling a home in Shelby County, it is important to use a top-rated real estate agency like White Stag. White Stag has a team of experienced and knowledgeable real estate agents. They can help you find the right home for your needs and budget, or sell your home quickly and for top dollar.

Here are some of the benefits of using White Stag:

  • Local expertise: White Stag’s real estate agents are experts in the Shelby County real estate market. They know the different neighborhoods and communities in the county and can help you find the perfect home for your needs.
  • Negotiation skills: White Stag’s real estate agents are skilled negotiators and can help you get a great deal on your home purchase or sale.
  • Marketing expertise: White Stag has a team of marketing experts who can help market your home to a wide range of buyers.
  • Customer service: White Stag is committed to providing excellent customer service to their clients. They will work with you throughout the home buying or selling process to make sure that you are happy with the results.

White Stag Realty provides top level service to residential sellers and buyers in Indiana to help our clients achieve their real estate goals while saving on commission!

For homeowners looking to sell, we offer discounted listing agent commission rates – as low as 1%! This means a homeowner can save THOUSANDS of dollars selling their home, retaining more of the equity from the property. In addition to our competitive rates, we provide full brokerage services for every transaction that match (and often exceed) the level of service provided by our competitors.

For clients looking to buy a home, White Stag agents find properties that meet specific search criteria, schedule and coordinate all showings, negotiate offers, request repairs noted from inspections, and get our clients to the closing table for their new home.

What makes White Stag Realty truly unique is that our agents are full-service realtors who represent our clients at a fraction of the cost of many of our competitors.

Many of our clients ask how we can provide full service real estate agents at such competitive rates. While commission rates are always negotiable, it is common for listing agents to charge a commission between 3 to 4%. These high commission rates were justified several decades ago. Buying or selling a home prior to the widespread usage of digital technology was indeed a slow process. For example, if a potential buyer wanted to see pictures of a home, the buyer’s agent had to coordinate with the seller’s agent to obtain physical photographs of the home from the seller’s agent, and then meet with the client in person merely to show the client actual pictures of the property. Similarly, if a client wanted to see a home in person, the buyer’s agent had to schedule the showing by phone, drive to the seller’s agent, get a key for the home from the seller’s agent, drive to the home, conduct the showing, and then drive back to the seller’s agent to return the key. Advances in technology, that we now take for granted, have significantly streamlined the process of buying or selling a home. These technological advances include automated syndication of MIBOR MLS listings to other real estate websites including Trulia and Zillow, bluetooth-enabled sentrilock lockboxes, and digital scheduling of showings. The process for buying or selling a home has become streamlined over the past few decades through the use of technology. Unfortunately, the monetary savings realtors have experienced have not been passed on to the public. The high commission rates seen in today’s market take advantage of trusting consumers. White Stag Realty was created to pass these savings on to our clients.

Whether you plan on acting in the near future, or are just looking ahead, if you have any questions, please do not hesitate to call. We look forward to hearing from you.

Specific Neighborhoods and/or Cities in the Area

Some of the most popular neighborhoods and cities in Shelby County, Indiana include:

  • Shelbyville: Shelbyville is the county seat and largest city in Shelby County. It is home to a variety of businesses and industries, as well as several schools and colleges.
  • Edinburgh: Edinburgh is a growing suburb of Indianapolis that is located just south of Shelbyville. It is known for its good schools and family-friendly atmosphere.
  • Fairland: Fairland is a small city that is located in the northern part of Shelby County. It is known for its rural setting and its proximity to Indianapolis.
  • Morristown: Morristown is a small town that is located in the southeastern part of Shelby County. It is known for its historic downtown area and its proximity to Blue River State Park.

Why This Area Is a Great Place to Live

There are many reasons why Shelby County is a great place to live. Here are just a few:

  • Cost of living: The cost of living in Shelby County is relatively low, which makes it a great place to live for people on a budget.
  • Economy: The economy in Shelby County is growing, which is creating new jobs and opportunities.
  • Amenities: Shelby County offers a variety of amenities, including parks, schools, and shopping.
  • Location: Shelby County is located in a desirable area of Indiana. It is close to Indianapolis, the state capital, and it is also close to several other major cities, such as Chicago and Cincinnati.

Advice for Both Home Buyers and Home Sellers in This Area

For Home Buyers, here are a few tips:

  • Get pre-approved for a mortgage: This will show sellers that you are serious about buying a home and that you are qualified to finance the purchase.
  • Work with a real estate agent: A good real estate agent can help you find the right home for your needs and budget, and they can also negotiate on your behalf.
  • Be prepared to act quickly: The real estate market in Shelby County is very competitive, so it is important to be prepared to act quickly when you find a home that you like.
  • Get to know the different neighborhoods in Shelby County. Each neighborhood has its own unique character and amenities. Consider your needs and budget when deciding which neighborhoods to focus on.
  • Be prepared to make a competitive offer. The housing market in Shelby County is competitive, so be prepared to make a competitive offer on homes that you are interested in.
  • Don’t be afraid to negotiate. If you find a home that you love, don’t be afraid to negotiate with the seller. Your real estate agent can help you with this process.
  • Be patient. The home buying process can be time-consuming, but it is important to be patient. Don’t rush into buying a home that is not right for you.

For Home Sellers, here are a few tips:

  • Price your home competitively: The best way to sell your home quickly and for top dollar is to price it competitively. Your real estate agent can help you determine the price for your home.
  • Make your home show-ready: This means making any necessary repairs and decluttering your home.
  • Market your home effectively: Work with your real estate agent to market your home to a wide range of buyers. This may include listing your home on multiple websites, hosting
  • Make sure your home is in good condition. Before you put your home on the market, make any necessary repairs and updates. This will make your home more appealing to buyers and will help you get a better price.
  • Be flexible. Be willing to negotiate with buyers and be flexible with your closing date. This will make your home more attractive to buyers and will help you sell your home more quickly.